Dr. Swelim versus Dr. Govedarica

Diese Seite ist noch in Arbeit!

(bb) Nach wie vor wird die Auseinandersetzung zwischen Wissenschaftlern um die 'Bosnischen Pyramiden' mit ungeheurer Schärfe ausgetragen. So konterte im April 2009 der Archäologe/Ägyptologe Dr. Nabil Swelim (Abb. 1) die von seinem Kollegen Dr. Blagoje Govedarica (Abb. 2) gegen ihn gerichteten Anwürfe mit der öffentlichen Feststellung: "Sie sind arrogant und haben keine wissenschaftlichen Qualifikationen, um über die Pyramiden zu reden!"

Abb. 1 Der Ägyptologe Dr. Nabil Swelim, Präsident der First International Scientific Conference on the Bosnian Valley of the Pyramids (ICBP 2008)

Mit dieser höchst harschen Kollegenschelte reagierte der dreifache PhD und Pyramiden-Spezialist, der im Jahr 2008 auch als Präsident der First International Scientific Conference on the Bosnian Valley of the Pyramids fungiert hatte, auf ein Interview to interview of the Bosnian archaeologist working in Germany Dr. Blagoje Govedarica published in the Sarajevo's daily newspaper "Oslobodjenje" and the statement of the press office of the Academy of Science of Bosnia and Herzegovina.

Dr. Blagoje Govedarica has written for the "Oslobodjenje" that "several Egyptian scientists presented the opinion that the pyramids existed in mid-Bosnia", that Egyptians "do not know the Bosnian archaeology", and that "the Egyptian experts are involved in the project just to help development of the tourist industry". Academy of Science and Arts of Bosnia and Herzegovina then announced that Dr. Govedarica was "the most eminent pre-historian in Europe."

Unlike Dr. Blagoje Govedarica, who has never studied the Bosnian Valley of the Pyramids nor has published any scientific work about the pyramids, Dr. Nabil Swelim, after the research in Visoko, has written comprehensive Archaeological Report, and is considered one of the most distinguished researchers of the pyramids in the world.

Abb. 2 Der Archäologe Dr. Blagoje Govedarica

In the letter to Dr. Govedarica Dr. Swelim highlights: "According to the Institute for Prehistory from Heidelberg you are a private docent, and according to the Academy of Science and Arts of Bosnia and Herzegovina you are the most eminent pre-historian in Europe. I know your superiors in Heidelberg, and they are known for their scientific competence and modesty. As far as you're concern, I can tell that you do not have scientific qualifications to speak about the pyramids. Nothing in your biography or in your modest bibliography can support that. "

In his letter Dr. Swelim explains Dr. Govedarica characteristics of pyramids: subjective (geometry, stability, orientation, concepts, local scenarios: Mexico, China, Bosnia) and objective (geology, archaeology, and architecture).

Dr. Swelim claims that these characteristics are present in the case of the Bosnian Pyramid Hills.

"Mr Govedarica, you try to discredit the discoverer of the pyramids in Visoko. For comparison: where are now those who were trying to discredit Galileo or Schlliman? Remember: you're talking way above your head, here!"

Dr. Swelim claims that Dr. Govedarica is the arrogant person who is unsettled because of the discovery of the Bosnian Pyramid Hills, saying that "Dr. Govedarica insulted him on several occasions".

In conclusion Dr. Swelim warned Dr. Govedarica not to divide the scientists on the basis of their nationality. "I am very proud that I am scientist from Egypt. You, professor Govedarica, do not have the scientific qualifications to judge the Pyramid hills in Bosnia."

Externa

Dr. Swelim's Brief an Dr. Govedarica (Engl.)

Dr. Swelim's Brief an "Oslobodjenje" (Engl.)

"Der herausragendste Prähistoriker in Europa" (Engl.)

Swelim-Govedarica Korrespondenz (Engl.)

Anmerkungen und Quellen

EGYPTOLOGIST DR. SWELIM TO DR. GOVEDARICA: "You are arrogant and have no scientific qualifications to talk about the pyramids!", Mitteilung von www.piramidasunca.ba vom 24.05.2009